The wrenching images and stories from Ukraine should spur NATO—a trans-Atlantic, defensive, military and political alliance—to think harder about how it would protect its citizens and critical infrastructure during a high-intensity, state-on-state conflict. Alliance leaders would be wise to press this point during the upcoming summit in Madrid, where the organization is slated to adopt a new strategic concept and agree on a definition of human security.
Civilians have always suffered in wartime, and even before Russia invaded Ukraine, it had become clear that a new war on European soil would be no different. Tabletop exercises we participated in over the years—including one last fall that our organization helped to design—point to the fact that defeating the adversary will remain a critical task. However, protecting alliance civilians and civilian infrastructure is likely to be equally important—and perhaps more challenging.
Ukraine’s tragic experience only underlines this. Its people are being killed by the Russian shelling of residential neighborhoods, forcibly displaced to Russia, and subjected to more atrocities. But they also die from lack of access to basic needs such as food, water, shelter, healthcare, and electricity. In a future conflict, countering these deadly threats will require a keen understanding of the human environment and the protection of civilians.
Read the full op-ed in Defense One.
Human Rights & IHL, Human Rights & IHL, Protection of Civilians
Share:
Originally published in Defense One.
The wrenching images and stories from Ukraine should spur NATO—a trans-Atlantic, defensive, military and political alliance—to think harder about how it would protect its citizens and critical infrastructure during a high-intensity, state-on-state conflict. Alliance leaders would be wise to press this point during the upcoming summit in Madrid, where the organization is slated to adopt a new strategic concept and agree on a definition of human security.
Civilians have always suffered in wartime, and even before Russia invaded Ukraine, it had become clear that a new war on European soil would be no different. Tabletop exercises we participated in over the years—including one last fall that our organization helped to design—point to the fact that defeating the adversary will remain a critical task. However, protecting alliance civilians and civilian infrastructure is likely to be equally important—and perhaps more challenging.
Ukraine’s tragic experience only underlines this. Its people are being killed by the Russian shelling of residential neighborhoods, forcibly displaced to Russia, and subjected to more atrocities. But they also die from lack of access to basic needs such as food, water, shelter, healthcare, and electricity. In a future conflict, countering these deadly threats will require a keen understanding of the human environment and the protection of civilians.
Read the full op-ed in Defense One.
Recent & Related
Building a Hornet’s Nest: The Promises and Challenges of US-Taiwan Drone Coproduction
Beyond Hormuz: The Sanaa Airport Strike and the Architecture of Iranian Proxy Power
Lebanon-Israel Security Annex Adds New Problems Without Solving Old Ones
NATO Summit Assessment: Partial Reversion to the Mean
Iran Uses Diplomacy and Coercion to Perpetuate Control of the Strait of Hormuz
From ‘Three Amigos’ to Distrustful Neighbors
Community Adaptation for a Water Festival Without Clean Water
Tripoli’s New Leverage: How the American Initiative Changed the Rules of Negotiation
America’s Chip Future Still Runs Through Taiwan
Postwar, Iran Is at a Crossroads
When Formal Alliances Stop Doing Political Work: The Canada-US Alliance in Crisis
Post-War Street Rallies in Iran: The Ascendance of Religious over National Identity
What Demographic Trends Mean for US Policy
Community Adaptation for a Water Festival Without Clean Water
การทำเหมืองแร่โดยไม่ได้รับการควบคุมตามแนวแม่น้ำในแผ่นดินใหญ่ของเอเชียตะวันออกเฉียงใต้
Navigating Seabed Mining in the Cook Islands: A Conversation with John Parianos
การทำเหมืองแร่โดยไม่ได้รับการควบคุมตามแนวแม่น้ำในแผ่นดินใหญ่ของเอเชียตะวันออกเฉียงใต้
Mining in Mainland Southeast Asia – River Basins Dashboard
Unregulated Mining Along Rivers in Mainland Southeast Asia
Trump’s Critical Minerals Search in Africa Won’t Tip the Scales Against China
Trump–Xi Summit: Expert Perspectives on the Stakes and Strategic Outlook
Breaking Silos to Beat Scams: Why Holistic Law Enforcement Matters
Find an Expert
Home to more than 100 scholars and global affiliates, the Stimson Center is proud to be a magnet for the world’s leading experts on the most pressing foreign policy and national security issues of our time. Explore our experts and their work.