Every November, representatives of governments, international organizations, businesses, and civil society convene in Paris for the annual meeting of the Paris Peace Forum, established in 2018. The timing deliberately overlaps with the Armistice Day holiday in order to highlight the value of diplomacy and multilateralism in preventing future conflicts.
The Forum regularly considers emerging technologies, and in 2026, this was no exception, as 14 governments adopted a set of new voluntary guidelines for the cyber intrusion industry. The Industry Guidelines were developed as part of the ongoing Pall Mall Process, which is a joint French and UK-led multistakeholder initiative to “tackle the proliferation and irresponsible use of commercial cyber intrusion capabilities.” One speaker described the Process as a “wrapper” that brings together fragmented efforts to curb mercenary spyware into a single dedicated forum.
The Industry Guidelines were developed through an iterative negotiated process allowing for input from governments, industry, and civil society stakeholders. The final document acknowledges and affirms the international legal frameworks that underpin it, including international human rights law, the UN Framework for Responsible State Behavior in Cyberspace, and the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights. It is organized across four pillars: compliance with regulations and norms, due diligence, risk management, and monitoring of compliance. Within each pillar are several recommended and more specific actions to take, ranging from compliance with export controls to implementing technical controls on access. As noted on its website, the objectives are to disincentivize irresponsible activity and improve transparency for regulators, vendors, and customers while also providing greater clarity for businesses within the industry.
The Guidelines build on and complement a 2024 voluntary Code of Practice for States, which is also organized across four pillars: accountability, precision, oversight, and transparency. The Code is currently endorsed by 27 countries.
Commercially available cyber intrusion capabilities (CCIC) are effectively long-form for spyware, although an important facet of this Process has been its emphasis on the full ecosystem of intrusion tools and services beyond spyware. These same tools are used for legitimate security research and in cyber defense, which has made governance and regulatory efforts complicated.
The Stimson Center has been contributing to the Pall Mall Process since its inception in 2024 through written submissions and participation in diverse global events. Senior Fellow and Cyber Program Director Allison Pytlak attended the November 2026 events in Paris and offers the following takeaways:
- The threats are real, and no one is immune. Persistent geopolitical tension is fueling demand for intrusion and surveillance tools, while rapid technological development and the spread of AI are lowering the barriers to entry and expanding threat surfaces. Citizen Lab’s new report exploring the first public confirmation of “AdFection” (zero-click spyware delivered via targeted ads), was referenced repeatedly during the conference because it highlights exactly this problem. Similarly, Apple’s new feature, which sends push notifications to users it suspects have been targeted with spyware, has already produced an estimated wave of alerts across 99 countries, reaching targets ranging from legislators and federal government employees in Germany to journalists in Turkey. While a lot of research about surveillance technology has looked at the harmful impact on elements of civil society, no one is immune; the repeated and growing targeting of government officials speaks to the national security threats posed by spyware, in addition to the significant human rights concerns.
- Civil society cannot carry this work alone. In the words of one speaker, civil society has been the “motor” of the engine driving action on this issue. For many years, organizations like Access Now, Amnesty Tech, and Citizen Lab, among others, have been at the forefront of documenting the harm caused by intrusion capabilities as well as attempting to make sense of one of the murkiest markets in existence. Together, they have assembled a significant evidence base for mobilizing advocacy and action, including as part of the Pall Mall Process. The burden of proof has been met, and what is needed now is the political will and resources for other actors to act on it.
- Will industry comply? A notable elephant in the conference rooms last week was the low participation from relevant industry actors. Industry participated in the process to draft the Guidelines, but few of the companies whose products and practices are of issue were present in Paris. It has also been observed that tech industry participants in the Pall Mall Process are largely not the companies and vendors of concern. Because the guidelines are voluntary, they will only matter if industry has real incentives to follow them, which makes government action on regulation, procurement, and export controls even more important.
- Accountability and impact. In a relatively short amount of time, the Pall Mall Process has made great strides in focusing multilateral attention on the problem of spyware and other commercial intrusion tools by developing frameworks like the Code and the Guidelines. Now, these documents need to be put into action. Multiple speakers stressed the importance of accountability in their statements, whether by imposing costs such as through sanctions, by supporting victims, or by adjusting their own activity. In addition, there is not yet a centralized mechanism by which Code-endorsing countries can report national-level action and through which to assess impact. The next phase should focus on helping countries turn their commitments into action, through capacity building and support, paired with a way to track what they do. As stated by the French Foreign Ministry, “A voluntary code is not, however, an optional code: one’s word, given before one’s peers, one’s industries, and one’s citizens, is a commitment.”

Community Adaptation for a Water Festival Without Clean Water