The cynical deal struck between the European Union and Turkey aimed at stemming the flow of refugees into Europe is a sign of desperation. It is flawed on several levels, and is likely to do harm to Europe’s image as a champion of international norms and Western values. Ironically, it will also probably do more harm than good to any hopes Turkey may still harbor for EU membership. But for all its shortcomings, the deal is better than doing nothing, and its effective implementation will help restore Europe’s self-confidence and Turkey’s role as a regional problem-solver.
The deal finalized Friday in Brussels to help curtail the irregular migration from Syria via Turkey to the EU went into effect this week. There is a careful balance of commitments from the two sides: an even swap of refugees and migrants currently in Greece to be returned to Turkey, with Syrian refugees currently in Turkey being permitted into the EU through a more formal screening process. In addition, Turkey will work to prevent the emergence of new sea and land routes, in exchange for EU efforts to speed up 6 billion euros in aid earmarked for refugees already in Turkey, and to accelerate a visa-liberalization policy for Turks to travel to Europe. The deal was painfully negotiated over many months, with German Chancellor Angela Merkel playing the key role, at considerable political risk.
Read the full article here.
The cynical deal struck between the European Union and Turkey aimed at stemming the flow of refugees into Europe is a sign of desperation. It is flawed on several levels, and is likely to do harm to Europe’s image as a champion of international norms and Western values. Ironically, it will also probably do more harm than good to any hopes Turkey may still harbor for EU membership. But for all its shortcomings, the deal is better than doing nothing, and its effective implementation will help restore Europe’s self-confidence and Turkey’s role as a regional problem-solver.
The deal finalized Friday in Brussels to help curtail the irregular migration from Syria via Turkey to the EU went into effect this week. There is a careful balance of commitments from the two sides: an even swap of refugees and migrants currently in Greece to be returned to Turkey, with Syrian refugees currently in Turkey being permitted into the EU through a more formal screening process. In addition, Turkey will work to prevent the emergence of new sea and land routes, in exchange for EU efforts to speed up 6 billion euros in aid earmarked for refugees already in Turkey, and to accelerate a visa-liberalization policy for Turks to travel to Europe. The deal was painfully negotiated over many months, with German Chancellor Angela Merkel playing the key role, at considerable political risk.
Read the full article here.
Recent & Related
Intergenerational Solidarity and Learning in an Era of Declining Trust
The UN Annually Votes on Ending the US Embargo on Cuba. What Does it Mean for Unilateral Sanctions and Their Impact on Human Rights?
Experts React: The Midterms and America’s Place in the World
The Lame-Duck Period is Full of Peril in the War on Iran
Is Reforming the UNSC Realistic? Article 27(3) of the UN Charter Offers a Starting Point.
Beyond the Populist Zeitgeist
A New Transatlantic Equilibrium
Forging a European Foreign Policy
A Superpower in Decline
What Is Going on in Cybersecurity?
The Implications of Ukraine’s Starshield Access for the US Military
Egypt’s Parallel Inc. & the Myth of Sovereign Efficiency
Find an Expert
Home to more than 100 scholars and global affiliates, the Stimson Center is proud to be a magnet for the world’s leading experts on the most pressing foreign policy and national security issues of our time. Explore our experts and their work.