The reported death of Ali Khamenei, Iran’s Supreme Leader since 1989, in an Israeli air strike, provides Iran with an opportunity to recalibrate policies that for nearly half a century have alienated the country from the United States and much of the Western world.
In the short term, Khamenei will be replaced by another cleric – likely already chosen – or by a small council of senior officials.
No significant policy changes can occur while U.S. and Israeli bombs are still falling on the country. But in the longer term, Iranian leaders may acknowledge the failure of Khamenei’s “resistance” strategy to protect the country from foreign attacks and to govern in a way that wins support from the Iranian people.
It is not clear whether U.S. officials or intermediaries have already reached out to any of Khamenei’s potential successors and proposed a path forward. President Donald Trump has issued only the vaguest of suggestions, urging Iranians to use the opportunity of U.S. and Israeli strikes to rise up and remove the regime in the wake of the attacks. His best bet for change, however, may lie within the system among pragmatists who have sought détente with Washington in the past. In this way, he could follow the example of Venezuela, where following the U.S. removal of President Nicolas Maduro, Vice President Delcy Rodriguez is cooperating with the United States.
One candidate is Ali Larijani, the head of Iran’s Supreme Council of National Security, a veteran member of the establishment who according to some accounts, has already been essentially governing in Khamenei’s stead. Larijani headed the same council 20 years ago when he sought talks with then U.S. national security adviser Stephen Hadley, as I reported in my book on U.S.-Iran relations. He also provided crucial parliamentary support to the Iranian government that negotiated the 2015 nuclear deal, the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), that Trump unilaterally quit in 2018 during his first term. The son of a famous ayatollah and the brother of a former judiciary chief, Larijani, 67, has been in the thick of the Islamic Republic’s politics for more than three decades.
Other potential interlocutors are the speaker of the parliament, Mohammad Baqer Qalibaf, and the former president and national security adviser Hassan Rouhani, on whose watch the JCPOA was reached. There may be other figures within the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) or the regular military that could emerge in the wake of the current crisis.
There are no guarantees that whoever follows Khamenei will be an improvement in terms of Iran’s domestic or foreign policies. But the huge popular protests of earlier this year that were brutally suppressed at the cost of thousands of Iranian lives, on top of the collapse of Iran’s network of regional allies following the Israeli retaliation for the Hamas attacks of Oct. 7, 2023, have exposed the Islamic Republic’s vulnerability more dramatically than at any time since the Iraqi invasion of the country in 1980.
Iranian society long ago evolved beyond the restrictions of the Islamic Republic and the cheers of some Iranians as U.S. and Israeli bombs fell is telling. Those who care about the Iranian people have to hope for a better future for the country even as they oppose a U.S. and Israeli military operation that has no justification in international law and no authorization from the U.S. Congress.
Middle East, North Africa
Share:
The reported death of Ali Khamenei, Iran’s Supreme Leader since 1989, in an Israeli air strike, provides Iran with an opportunity to recalibrate policies that for nearly half a century have alienated the country from the United States and much of the Western world.
In the short term, Khamenei will be replaced by another cleric – likely already chosen – or by a small council of senior officials.
No significant policy changes can occur while U.S. and Israeli bombs are still falling on the country. But in the longer term, Iranian leaders may acknowledge the failure of Khamenei’s “resistance” strategy to protect the country from foreign attacks and to govern in a way that wins support from the Iranian people.
It is not clear whether U.S. officials or intermediaries have already reached out to any of Khamenei’s potential successors and proposed a path forward. President Donald Trump has issued only the vaguest of suggestions, urging Iranians to use the opportunity of U.S. and Israeli strikes to rise up and remove the regime in the wake of the attacks. His best bet for change, however, may lie within the system among pragmatists who have sought détente with Washington in the past. In this way, he could follow the example of Venezuela, where following the U.S. removal of President Nicolas Maduro, Vice President Delcy Rodriguez is cooperating with the United States.
One candidate is Ali Larijani, the head of Iran’s Supreme Council of National Security, a veteran member of the establishment who according to some accounts, has already been essentially governing in Khamenei’s stead. Larijani headed the same council 20 years ago when he sought talks with then U.S. national security adviser Stephen Hadley, as I reported in my book on U.S.-Iran relations. He also provided crucial parliamentary support to the Iranian government that negotiated the 2015 nuclear deal, the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), that Trump unilaterally quit in 2018 during his first term. The son of a famous ayatollah and the brother of a former judiciary chief, Larijani, 67, has been in the thick of the Islamic Republic’s politics for more than three decades.
Other potential interlocutors are the speaker of the parliament, Mohammad Baqer Qalibaf, and the former president and national security adviser Hassan Rouhani, on whose watch the JCPOA was reached. There may be other figures within the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) or the regular military that could emerge in the wake of the current crisis.
There are no guarantees that whoever follows Khamenei will be an improvement in terms of Iran’s domestic or foreign policies. But the huge popular protests of earlier this year that were brutally suppressed at the cost of thousands of Iranian lives, on top of the collapse of Iran’s network of regional allies following the Israeli retaliation for the Hamas attacks of Oct. 7, 2023, have exposed the Islamic Republic’s vulnerability more dramatically than at any time since the Iraqi invasion of the country in 1980.
Iranian society long ago evolved beyond the restrictions of the Islamic Republic and the cheers of some Iranians as U.S. and Israeli bombs fell is telling. Those who care about the Iranian people have to hope for a better future for the country even as they oppose a U.S. and Israeli military operation that has no justification in international law and no authorization from the U.S. Congress.
Recent & Related
The EU’s Technocratic Trap in Libya: How Brussels Is Ceding the Mediterranean
The Sovereignty Paradox: Why GCC Security Integration Remains Elusive
Japan’s Tentative Entry Into a Shifting Global Arms Market
The Time is Ripe for Next Steps on US-Japan Military Shipbuilding Cooperation
Israel Cannot Achieve Normalization with Lebanon by Bombing It
Sudan: How One of the Most Severe Humanitarian Crises Became Marginalized in the Global System
Beneath the Strait: Iran Could Threaten Gulf Data Centers, Undersea Cables
Mali’s Post-Alignment Strategy: Sovereignty, Partnerships, and the Limits of Stabilization
Turkey Also Tries to Mediate an End to the US-Israeli War on Iran
The Motives and Constraints Behind Pakistan’s Mediation Between the US and Iran
The Impact of US-Sponsored Ukraine-Russia Talks on Moldova’s Security
Smuggling Sovereignty: What Arkenu Reveals About Libya’s Fragmented Oil State
การทำเหมืองแร่โดยไม่ได้รับการควบคุมตามแนวแม่น้ำในแผ่นดินใหญ่ของเอเชียตะวันออกเฉียงใต้
ການຂຸດຄົ້ນ-ປຸງແຕ່ງແຮ່ທີ່ບໍ່ຖືກຕ້ອງ ຢູ່ຕາມແມ່ນໍ້າສາຍຕ່າງໆ ຢູ່ແຜ່ນດິນໃຫຍ່ອາຊີຕາເວັນອອກສຽງໃຕ້ Unregulated Mining Along Rivers in Mainland Southeast Asia (Lao Language)
Current Geopolitics Shift Deep-Sea Mining Debates
Navigating Seabed Mining in the Cook Islands: A Conversation with John Parianos
การทำเหมืองแร่โดยไม่ได้รับการควบคุมตามแนวแม่น้ำในแผ่นดินใหญ่ของเอเชียตะวันออกเฉียงใต้
Mining in Mainland Southeast Asia – River Basins Dashboard
Unregulated Mining Along Rivers in Mainland Southeast Asia
Trump’s Critical Minerals Search in Africa Won’t Tip the Scales Against China
North Korea’s Integration of AI Across Cyber, Economic, and Military Domains
AI in the Age of Fake (Imagined) Content
Find an Expert
Home to more than 100 scholars and global affiliates, the Stimson Center is proud to be a magnet for the world’s leading experts on the most pressing foreign policy and national security issues of our time. Explore our experts and their work.