Cyber Deterrence

Conducting research and multi-stakeholder cyber diplomacy, identifying practical approaches to improving deterrence of malicious cyber activities

In Emerging Technology Research

Cyberattacks represent a persistent and complex challenge for states, corporations, and individuals. Despite years of effort, the continued frequency and impact of malicious cyber activity suggests that no effective approach to “cyber deterrence” has yet been established. There is a long-running debate among academics and policy experts about the applicability of traditional concepts of deterrence to the cyber domain. However, there is growing consensus that some characteristics of cyber operations and capabilities render many traditional approaches to deterrence inadequate or inapplicable. These limitations create a broad lack of accountability for cyberattacks and malicious activity. As a result, there is an urgent need to identify practical and actor-specific means to deter such activity.

The Stimson Center’s Cyber Program is working to advance practical understandings of cyber deterrence, including in relation to concepts of accountability, to develop more effective policy approaches to deterring malicious cyber activities in the U.S. and globally. This project builds on the Cyber Accountability project, as well as the work of the Defense Strategy and Planning Project team on deterrence.

The project is jointly implemented by the Cyber Program and the Defense Strategy and Planning Project team.

Project Team
Research
Project Lead
Project Support
Project Support

Research & Writing

Commentary
Recent events shine a spotlight on evolving U.S. positions on cyber deterrence and offensive operations. What does this mean for accountability?
Allison Pytlak
Report
Bridging deterrence theory with accountability mechanisms, including legal procedures, sanctions, and beyond
James Siebens • Allison Pytlak • Kathleen Scoggin
Commentary
Exploring the proposal for a U.S. Cyber Force
Allison Pytlak • Dan Grazier
Field Note
Stimson’s Cyber Program co-facilitated a multi-stakeholder workshop on “Global and Actor-Specific Perspectives on Cyber Accountability and Deterrence” in Brussels
James Siebens • Allison Pytlak