Afghanistan and Pakistan: The Graveyard for US Foreign Policy Planning?
October 08, 2009
The foreign policy machinery in the Obama administration is finally grinding away on a difficult long-term policy and institutional problem: What should the US development and foreign assistance strategy be? Such an examination raises a seemingly endless set of questions: What roles should the Defense Department, State Department, and USAID play in the development, security, and foreign assistance mix? How should these agencies tackle their responsibilities in fragile and post-conflict states? What should be the long-term structure of the US military with respect to traditional combat missions and counterinsurgency missions? And, for the first time in history, what should be the long-term missions and capabilities of State and USAID?
The foreign policy establishment is taking these questions seriously. Defense is focusing on the next Quadrennial Defense Review, State is beginning its first Quadrennial Diplomacy and Development Review, and the National Security Council is undertaking broad interagency reviews of US development, foreign, and security assistance programs and authorities. Despite this foreign policy soul-searching, the legacy of the last eight years is handcuffing the administration in the short term. All signs point to the United States pursuing a path of nationbuilding again, and it appears as though it will start in the two places that could sink all three longer-term planning exercises: Afghanistan and Pakistan.
This relates to…
April 28, 2010
Afghanistan
April 20, 2010
South Asia
In 2013, the Stimson Center's South Asia programming has four key elements: reducing nuclear dangers and increasing deterrence stability on the subcontinent; analyzing crisis
… Read More »
April 20, 2010
Budgeting for Foreign Affairs and Defense
The Budgeting for Foreign Affairs and Defense program blog provides current news and analysis on a variety of issues related to national security. The
… Read More »
April 29, 2009
Pakistan’s Future and US Assistance
News reports of the Taliban's mostly uncontested advances in Pakistan's North-West Frontier Province have prompted panicky assessments and remedies. The situation in Pakistan clearly
… Read More »
October 27, 2008
Afghanistan and Pakistan: More Realism Needed to Prevent US Failure
By Amit Pandya
The Challenge
Afghanistan and Pakistan present distinct challenges to US policy. Yet they are closely linked by the political, historical and cultural unities that span
… Read More »
February 26, 2004
Trading Militancy for Peace in South Asia
Another effort to normalize India-Pakistan relations begins this week, when diplomats meet to discuss the structure of a substantive dialogue likely to follow the Indian elections in
… Read More »
June 28, 2003
Security and Peace Support in Afghanistan: Analysis and Short- to Medium-Term Options
This briefing applies to Afghanistan the strategic lessons learned from international peace implementation efforts in nearly twenty war-torn countries around the globe over the past
… Read More »
June 01, 2002
Peace and Stability in Afghanistan
U.S. goals in Afghanistan are broad and clear: root out al Qaeda and the Taliban forces, prevent their return, support self-governance, and ensure security, stability
… Read More »
June 01, 2002
Security in Afghanistan: The International Security Assistance Force (ISAF)
In the aftermath of September 11 and the U.S.-led operations against terrorist forces in Afghanistan, the United Nations Security Council authorized establishment of a 5,000-strong
… Read More »